Leaf litter and mossy deadfall on a damp woodland floor in flat overcast light

Teeth first. The tooth row tells you what the animal was equipped to eat, which is the biggest single cut you can make, and the eye sockets then tell you whether it hunted or was hunted. Size and outline are the glance you take before that, not the reading. Work in that order.

That sequence is not arbitrary. It is the one the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation lays out in its skull guide, and it works because each pass narrows the candidate list before the next one starts. A chart gives you the answer; the reading order is what makes a chart usable.

The glance before the reading

New York’s guidance opens with the shape of the whole thing: if you find an entire mammal skull, the first thing to look at is its general size and shape. Is it large like a deer or small like a rabbit? Is the skull streamlined and narrow like an opossum, or broader and rounder like a raccoon? Are there teeth, and if so, how many, and what do they look like?

That takes a second and it is worth the second, but it does not decide anything on its own. Put a coin or a ruler in the frame before you photograph, and shoot from directly above and from the side, because your state wildlife agency’s key will want a length and those two angles carry everything the rest of this reading needs.

Teeth, and what they say about the diet

The National Park Service lists four tooth types and what each does. Incisors cut, bite, nibble and strip, and sit at the front of the mouth. Canines grab, pierce and tear, and sit on either side of the incisors. Premolars grind, crush and slice. Molars grind and crush, using the leverage of the jaw for the most power.

From those, three diet groups fall out.

Carnivores. The Park Service describes canines and long teeth that enable an animal to bite and tear, with even the molars, which grind meat, being sharp. New York adds the feature worth learning by name: the carnassials, the last upper premolar and the first lower molar, which meet with a scissors-like action. Sharp, pointed canines and carnassials are used for tearing and shearing meat, and their presence indicates a carnivore.

Herbivores. The Park Service gives tall molar teeth with flat upper surfaces, sometimes ridged, plus clipper-like incisors. New York’s version is broad, somewhat flat teeth used for crushing and grinding vegetation.

Omnivores. The Park Service describes sharp long canines together with wide molar teeth that have low bumpy crowns, teeth that can both tear and cut and also grind and chew. New York puts it as sharp teeth in the front to rip and cut, and flattened teeth in the back to mash, and names raccoons and humans as examples.

The condition of the teeth is a second reading. New York notes that heavily worn, damaged and cracked teeth may indicate an old animal, while chipped, broken or missing teeth, or broken bones, could mean the animal was in an accident or a fight.

The ridge on top

The sagittal crest is the feature most people walk past. New York describes it as a ridge on top of the skull in carnivores and omnivores, the attachment site for the strong muscle that controls the crushing lower jaw. It is quite pronounced on opossum and fisher, and less pronounced on coyote, raccoon and otter. Herbivores typically have smaller jaw muscles and lack an obvious crest.

So a ridge running front to back along the midline of the braincase points at a meat-capable animal, and New York’s own ranking of how pronounced it is, from opossum and fisher down to coyote, raccoon and otter, is the useful detail. A smooth, rounded braincase with no obvious ridge points at a plant eater.

Eye sockets: hunter or hunted

New York gives the rule and the reason together. Predators such as coyote and otter generally have forward-facing eyes, which provides 3-D vision and lets them locate and follow prey more accurately. Prey species such as rabbits have relatively large eyes located on the sides of the head, which gives them peripheral vision and warns them about approaching danger.

The Park Service teaches the same thing to schoolchildren with a line worth stealing: eyes on the front, to hunt, eyes on the side, to hide. Its ranger program at Sequoia and Kings Canyon builds the whole exercise this way, asking students to determine whether an animal is predator or prey from orbit size, eye placement and teeth, and to work out whether it ate plants, meat or both from the teeth and the movement of the lower jaw.

Hold the photograph at eye level and ask which way the sockets point. Forward-facing puts the animal among the hunters and the omnivores, which is where New York places coyote, otter and raccoon. Out to the sides, near the top of the head, is an animal that spent its life watching for one. Read it alongside the teeth rather than on its own, because eye placement alone does not separate a predator from an omnivore.

What a skull will not tell you

The species, often, because closely related animals converge. A coyote skull and a large domestic dog skull sit in the same size class with the same tooth types, and the same is true of a bobcat against a large house cat, or a gray fox against a red one. Those separate on measurements and tooth counts taken with calipers rather than on anything a photograph carries, and the person who can resolve them is a mammalogist at your state agency or a university collection.

New York also cautions against reading the diet too literally: animals are highly variable within a species and adjust to what is available, so coyotes eat fruit, raccoons and opossums may be entirely carnivorous or vegetarian depending on the season, and deer have been observed eating fish. The skull tells you what the animal was equipped to eat, which is not the same as what it ate.

Before you take it home

Check the law first, because it is stricter than most people expect and it is not about mammals alone. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s national forensics laboratory states that possession of feathers and other parts of native North American birds without a permit is prohibited by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, that this extends to all feathers regardless of how they were obtained, and that there is no exemption for molted feathers or for those taken from road-killed or window-killed birds. The same page states that individuals or institutions wishing to use bird feathers, bones or whole specimens for educational or research purposes must apply for permits, so a bird skull found in the woods falls under it. Mammals are governed by your state’s own wildlife regulations, which vary a great deal, so check your state agency’s rules before collecting anything.

Photographing it is always allowed, and a photograph plus a location is what a wildlife biologist actually wants from you anyway.

One honest note about the app. Animal Identifier works from a photograph of the animal itself, taken with the camera or chosen from your gallery, and returns a species with its Latin name, taxonomy, habitat, diet and behavior along with a match percentage, which is a confidence figure rather than a verdict. It does not identify skulls, bones, tracks or scat. Use the reading order above and your state agency’s key for the skull, and keep the app for the animal that is still walking around.

The field-sign guides cover tracks and scat for the same species, sorting scat by shape, content and place is the other half of what a skull find usually sits next to, the first snow is the best week of the year for tracking covers reading a trail, and what animal is this is the walk-through for a living animal in frame.

Sources