Count the legs before anything else. Six legs and three body regions is an insect; eight legs and two body regions is an arachnid, meaning a spider, mite, tick, scorpion or harvestman; more than eight means a centipede, a millipede or a sowbug, none of which are insects. That one look removes most of the wrong answers.
It is a better first move than color, shape or size, because it is categorical. Colorado State University Extension’s arthropod notes lay the groups out this way and it is worth knowing that even the professionals stop well short of a species name. Actual identification of an insect to genus and species, the same guide says, requires a very high level of expertise. The realistic goal for a photo on a basement step is a group, and a group is usually the answer the question was really asking.
What do the legs and body sections tell you?
Six legs, three body regions. That is an insect. Colorado State describes the insect body as roughly 21 hardened ring-like segments arranged into head, thorax and abdomen, with a pair of legs attached to each of the three thorax segments. All adult insects also carry a pair of segmented antennae, and the guide notes that the many variations in antenna form are often used in identification.
Eight legs, two body regions. That is an arachnid. Colorado State describes spiders, mites, ticks, scorpions and harvestmen as having four pairs of legs and two body regions: the cephalothorax, which is head and thorax fused, and the abdomen. No antennae. If you count eight legs, stop looking through insect guides entirely.
Seven pairs of legs, two pairs of antennae. That is a sowbug or a pillbug, which Colorado State describes as land crustaceans with usually five to seven pairs of legs, two pairs of antennae and two body regions. The guide gives the field separation between the two: the pillbug will roll into a ball and the sowbug cannot.
A leg pair on every segment. Now you are in the many-legged groups, and they split cleanly. Millipedes have two pairs of legs per body segment except the first three, a usually cylindrical body 1 to 1½ inches (2.5 to 3.8 cm) long, short antennae, and anywhere from 15 to 150 body segments with 30 being common. Centipedes have flattened bodies with typically 40 to 50 segments and one pair of legs per segment. Penn State Extension puts the house centipede, the leggy fast one most people meet indoors, at 3 to 4 inches (8 to 10 cm) including antennae and legs, and gives the same 1 to 1½ inch (2.5 to 3.8 cm) figure for a millipede that Colorado State does.
What do the wings add?
A lot, and they are the second thing to look for once you have six legs.
Colorado State notes that insects may have one or two pairs of wings or none, and that the wings attach to the rear two thorax segments. The arrangement of the veins differs by species and is often a means of identification, which is why a wing photographed flat is worth more than a wing photographed folded.
The one wing feature worth memorizing is the beetle’s. Colorado State notes that on beetles the thickened front wing, called the elytra, serves for protection when the animal is not in flight, and that wing surfaces across insects are covered with fine hairs, scales, or are bare. A hard, opaque, protective front wing laid over the back is the fastest way to recognize a beetle from above, and a dusty scaled wing surface points at the moths and butterflies.
Mouthparts are a real order-level cue as well, though you will rarely resolve them on a phone. Colorado State separates chewing mandibles that move horizontally, the piercing and sucking mouthparts typical of true bugs, aphids, scales, lice, fleas, mosquitoes and biting flies, the coiled siphoning tube of butterflies and moths, and the lapping type found in flies.
Size, and the indoor shortlist
Put a coin or the edge of a light switch in the frame. Nobody estimates a quarter inch correctly on a dim floor, and the figures below are what the guides actually key on.
Penn State Extension publishes an urban pest list with measurements for the animals that turn up in houses. Bed bug adult, 3/16 inch (5 mm). German cockroach adult, 1/2 to 5/8 inch (13 to 16 mm). American cockroach adult, 1½ to 2 inches (38 to 50 mm). Oriental cockroach adult, 1¼ inch (32 mm). Pavement ant worker, 3/32 to 1/8 inch (2.5 to 3.0 mm), with all workers a similar size. Carpenter ant colony workers, 1/4 to 1/2 inch (6 to 13 mm) with workers of varying sizes, and that difference in worker uniformity is itself a useful check. House fly adult, 1/8 to 1/4 inch (3 to 6 mm). Fruit fly adult, 1/8 inch (3 mm). Brown marmorated stink bug adult, 1/2 inch (13 mm). Termite adult, 1/4 inch (6 mm). Webbing clothes moth, 1/4 inch (6 mm), with a mature larva at 1/2 inch (13 mm).
Silverfish are the most-photographed indoor insect that people cannot name, and they are distinctive once you know the three features. The University of California’s pest note describes them as slender, wingless and soft-bodied, tapering gradually from front to rear, with two long slender antennae and a body ending in three long thin tail-like appendages. Silverfish are shiny silver or pearl gray and about 1/2 inch (13 mm) long, though one can grow as long as 3/4 inch (1.9 cm); firebrats are the same length and a mottled gray or brown. Penn State gives silverfish as 1/4 to 1/2 inch (6 to 13 mm), which is the normal kind of range disagreement between two guides and a reason to treat any single figure as approximate. The habitat separates them too: silverfish favor damp warm places such as laundry rooms, while firebrats favor very warm dry spots around ovens, heating units, fireplaces, hot water pipes, and attics in summer.
How far can a photo get you?
To an order, usually. To a family, often. To a species, rarely, and the reason is the same one that governs spiders. The Burke Museum’s arachnology note explains that within a family, species are separated mostly by fine structures that cannot be seen without high magnification, and that color patterns can be very variable within a species and very similar between different species. Insects are not as extreme, but the direction is identical.
Colorado State lists when identification gets hard, and the list reads like a description of most indoor bug photos: the insect is too small to show its characteristics, it is not associated with any damage, it has atypical characteristics for its order, or it has moved on and left only the damage behind. Shoot from directly above with a scale reference, then again from the side, and get one frame with the antennae and legs fully extended.
If something has bitten or stung, contact a poison center or a doctor. The National Capital Poison Center’s instruction is to call 1-800-222-1222 or use the webPOISONCONTROL online tool at triage.webpoisoncontrol.org, and to seek help if local symptoms worsen significantly, if systemic symptoms develop, or if you have a history of allergic reactions. Do not catch the animal for identification; the photo is enough.
Once the legs are counted and the frame is sharp, a name is the fast part. Animal Identifier reads a photo of the animal itself, from the camera or your gallery, and returns a species with its Latin name, taxonomy, habitat, diet and behavior along with a match percentage, which is a confidence figure rather than a verdict. On small arthropods, treat the result as a strong starting point and check it against your state extension service’s list for the group.
What animal is this is the general walk-through for a photo in hand, identifying a spider from a picture covers the eight-legged half of this question in detail, how to photograph an animal you cannot get close to covers getting a frame worth submitting, and the field-sign guides cover the larger animals that leave marks rather than appearing on the stairs.
Sources
- CMG GardenNotes: Identifying Insects, Taxonomy of Arthropods and Insect Anatomy, Colorado State University Extension
- Common Urban Pests: Identification, Prevention, and Control, Penn State Extension
- Silverfish and Firebrats, Pest Notes 7475, University of California Statewide Integrated Pest Management Program
- Myth: You identify spiders by markings, Burke Museum of Natural History and Culture
- Insect and spider bites: When to worry, National Capital Poison Center