A snow-covered logging road through young spruce and fir in flat winter light, no tracks on it yet

Look at the tail tip and the feet. A Canada lynx has a short tail whose tip is black all the way around, and feet so large and furred they look borrowed from a bigger animal. A bobcat’s tail tip is black on top and white underneath, and its feet fit the cat. Check the map first; it rules one animal out almost everywhere.

Bobcat vs lynx comes down to three features that survive distance. Vermont Fish and Wildlife says the lynx tail tip is completely black all around where the bobcat’s shows white underneath; Maine gives the lynx feet as snowshoe-like and its ear tufts as 1 inch (2.5 cm) or longer. Weight overlaps, so size alone cannot call it.

Why the tail tip and not the size?

Because the two animals are close in size and the size difference people expect is mostly leg length.

The Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife says that although lynx are similar in size and appearance to bobcats, lynx appear larger because of their long legs. Maine’s own figures put an adult male lynx at about 33½ inches (85 cm) long and 26 to 30 pounds (12 to 14 kg), and a female at about 32 inches (81 cm) and 17 to 20 pounds (7.7 to 9 kg). New York’s Department of Environmental Conservation gives male bobcats an average body length of 34 inches (86 cm) and an average weight of 21 pounds (9.5 kg), with females at 30 inches (76 cm) and 14 pounds (6.4 kg), and notes that large individuals of either sex can exceed 30 pounds (14 kg). The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife gives the lynx a wider band still, 11 to 38 pounds (5 to 17 kg).

Lay those ranges side by side and a 25 pound (11 kg) cat could be either animal. That is why Maine, Vermont and Colorado all put the feet and the tail ahead of the scale in their comparisons.

The tail is the cue that works on a photograph. Vermont Fish and Wildlife puts it plainly: lynx tails appear much the same viewed from top or bottom, and the tip is completely black all around, where bobcat tails show black bars with a white tip when viewed from above and show a lot of white underneath. Colorado Parks and Wildlife describes the lynx tail tip as black on top and bottom, as if dipped in a jar of ink, and the bobcat’s as white underneath and black on top. Maine adds that the lynx tail is also the shorter of the two. If the animal walks away from you, which it usually does, the underside of the tail is the one feature it hands you for free.

What do the feet look like?

Out of proportion, on a lynx. Maine calls the large, densely furred feet the most distinguishing characteristic of the species and compares them to snowshoes. New York says bobcats can be told from lynx by the absence of those huge, seemingly oversized paws, and have paws proportional to their body size, with shorter legs and a stockier appearance. Vermont says lynx feet are snowshoe-like and at least twice the size of bobcat feet.

That difference carries straight into the snow. Maine’s checklist gives a lynx track as larger than 3 inches (7.6 cm) and a bobcat track as about 2 inches (5 cm). New York says lynx tracks are roughly twice the size of a bobcat’s. If you have a print rather than the animal, the bobcat or mountain lion guide and the mountain lion tracks guide cover how to measure a cat track and what a melting print does to the number, and the first-snow tracking post explains why a track measured a day after the snowfall reads larger than the foot that made it.

The ears, the legs and the coat

These three help when the tail is hidden, and they rank in that order.

Ear tufts. Both cats have them. Maine’s checklist gives lynx tufts as 1 inch (2.5 cm) or longer and bobcat tufts as absent to 1 inch (2.5 cm). Colorado describes the lynx as having long ear tufts and a beard, the bobcat short ones. On a head-on trail camera frame the tufts are often the clearest thing in the picture.

The stance. Both Maine and Colorado describe the same silhouette. Maine says the hind end of a lynx is slightly raised where the back of a bobcat is relatively flat. Colorado says a lynx standing on flat ground has its hips higher than its shoulders because of its longer back legs, where a bobcat’s shoulders and hips are much more level. Vermont calls the result a stooped appearance. A cat that looks like it is walking slightly downhill on level ground is showing you lynx legs.

The coat. This is the weakest of the three, because bobcat spotting varies so much. Vermont describes lynx pelts as relatively bland and grayish, and bobcat pelts as reddish brown with more distinct spots and streaks. Maine’s checklist gives the lynx a uniform coat and the bobcat a less uniform one, with a white underbelly and spots. New York adds the detail that most people miss: the degree of spotting on a bobcat is highly variable across its range, and in New York most bobcats have faint or indistinct spots. New York also notes the black bars on a bobcat’s forelegs and the white spots on the backs of its ears, and Colorado lists the spots and stripes on the sides of a bobcat’s legs against less spotting on a lynx. A plain gray cat is suggestive of lynx. It is not proof.

Where are you standing?

Range does more work than any feature, and it should be the first thing you check rather than the last.

Washington says Canada lynx once occurred throughout the state’s northern counties and that somewhere between 40 and 100 likely remain today, in the North Cascades and the state’s other northern mountain ranges. Maine, which has the largest lynx population in the lower 48, says lynx are most common in the spruce and fir flats of Aroostook and Piscataquis counties and are unlikely to be seen in southern or central Maine, where bobcats are more common. New York says the lynx is currently considered extirpated in the state, while bobcats are well established everywhere outside New York City and Long Island.

Maine’s page lists where lynx occur in the lower 48: Maine, Minnesota, Montana and Washington, a reintroduced population in Colorado, and parts of northern New Hampshire and Vermont. A gray cat with tufted ears anywhere outside those places is almost certainly a bobcat; the agencies’ range accounts leave little room for anything else, and the feature list is only there to confirm it. If you are inside them, Colorado Parks and Wildlife puts exactly the features above, the tail tip, the feet, the ear tufts and the stance, in front of anyone about to report a lynx sighting, which tells you what a biologist reading the report wants to see.

One more thing clears up most of the confusion in the comments under any comparison article. The bobcat is a lynx. Its scientific name is Lynx rufus, and the animal everyone means by “lynx” in North America is the Canada lynx, Lynx canadensis, the name New York’s page uses. The question is never whether the cat is a lynx. It is which one.

When the two cannot be told apart

A cat that is moving, half behind brush, or caught in a single blurred frame may not resolve at all, and the honest answer is to say so. Vermont’s guidance was written for hunters and trappers, but it applies to anyone trying to name the animal: it may be difficult or impossible to positively identify a moving or partially hidden animal as a lynx or bobcat. If you have no clear view of the tail tip, no sense of the feet, and the animal is inside bobcat range, call it a bobcat and let the agency confirm anything rarer.

Photograph the animal from where you are standing and use the zoom. The frame you want is a side view with the tail visible, or the animal walking away with the underside of the tail showing. That frame is what Animal Identifier works from: a photo of the animal itself, from the camera or your gallery, returned as a species with its Latin name, taxonomy, habitat, diet and behavior and a match percentage, which is a confidence figure rather than a verdict. On this pair the useful frame is the one with the tail or the feet in it; a head-on shot of a gray face with tufts gives the app less to work with, for the same reason it gives you less. What animal is this covers how to get a usable photo of any animal you cannot approach.

Sources